Comparison
MacroFactor vs MyFitnessPal
MacroFactor vs MyFitnessPal is a choice between two approaches. MacroFactor is a paid, ad-free app built around an adaptive algorithm that learns your real calorie needs. MyFitnessPal is the familiar free tracker with a huge database, where the best features are in Premium.
Here's how they compare on coaching, price, logging and data. We make Caloroo and mention it as a third option at the end.
By the Caloroo team · Competitor prices and features checked November 2026. Check the official sites for current pricing.
The short answer
- Choose MacroFactor if you want an app that coaches your calorie and macro targets every week, with no ads, and you're happy to pay.
- Choose MyFitnessPal if you want a free tracker and the largest food database, or you rely on its integrations.
- Consider Caloroo if you want an expenditure estimate from your own data and free barcode scanning, without a subscription.
MacroFactor vs MyFitnessPal vs Caloroo at a glance
| Feature | MacroFactor | MyFitnessPal | Caloroo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No, free trial only | Yes | Yes |
| Paid plan | About $11.99/month or $71.99/year | Premium: about $19.99/month or $79.99/year (US) | Premium price not yet announced |
| Adaptive expenditure (TDEE) | Yes, core feature with weekly check-ins | No, formula-based goals | Yes, estimate from logged food and weight trend |
| Barcode scanner | Included | Premium only | Free |
| Ads | None | On the free plan | None |
| Food database | Curated, smaller | Very large, mostly user-entered | Smaller, growing |
| Calorie target | Daily, with customizable weekly distribution | Daily | Daily targets inside a weekly budget |
| Social and sharing | Solo | Friends and community forums | Groups for partners, families and coaches |
Adaptive TDEE vs a fixed calorie goal
MyFitnessPal sets your calorie goal from a formula based on your age, height, weight and activity level. Formulas can be off by hundreds of calories, and the goal doesn't learn from your results.
MacroFactor estimates your expenditure from your logged intake and weight trend, then updates your targets at weekly check-ins. If your weight isn't moving as expected, the targets adjust. This is MacroFactor's main advantage.
Price: is MacroFactor worth it over MyFitnessPal?
MacroFactor costs about $11.99 a month or $71.99 a year, and there's no free version. MyFitnessPal is free to use, but Premium costs about $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year in the US. On an annual plan, MacroFactor is cheaper than MyFitnessPal Premium.
So the question is really whether you'd pay for MyFitnessPal Premium anyway. If you would, MacroFactor gives you adaptive coaching for less. If you only need a free diary, MyFitnessPal's free plan does that.
Logging and the food database
MacroFactor's logging is fast and its database is curated, so entries are more consistent. MyFitnessPal's database is far bigger, so you'll find more restaurant and regional foods, but duplicate and inaccurate entries are common. On MyFitnessPal's free plan you can't scan barcodes.
A free option with an expenditure estimate: Caloroo
If you like MacroFactor's idea but don't want a subscription, Caloroo is free and estimates expenditure from your own data. Caloroo estimates your daily expenditure from up to 28 days of logged food and your weight trend. Until it has about three weeks of complete logs, it blends in a formula estimate based on your profile. It needs weigh-ins and a complete profile (sex, age, height).
It doesn't have MacroFactor's structured weekly coaching. It does add a weekly calorie budget and groups for tracking with a partner, family or coach.
Which should you choose?
Choose MacroFactor if…
- You want weekly coaching of your targets.
- You'd rather pay than see ads.
- You want a curated database.
Choose MyFitnessPal if…
- You want a free tracker.
- You need the biggest database.
- You rely on its integrations or community.
Choose Caloroo if…
- You want an expenditure estimate for free.
- You want free barcode scanning, no ads.
- You track with a partner, family or coach.
Frequently asked questions
Is MacroFactor better than MyFitnessPal?
For data-driven calorie targets, yes. MacroFactor adapts your targets to your real results, while MyFitnessPal uses a fixed formula. MyFitnessPal is better if you want a free app or the largest food database.
Is MacroFactor cheaper than MyFitnessPal Premium?
On annual plans, yes, at the time of writing: about $71.99 a year for MacroFactor versus about $79.99 a year for MyFitnessPal Premium in the US. MyFitnessPal also has a free plan; MacroFactor doesn't.
Does MyFitnessPal have adaptive TDEE?
No. MyFitnessPal sets your goal with a formula. You can change it by hand, but it doesn't learn from your weight trend the way MacroFactor or Caloroo's expenditure estimate does.
Can I switch from MyFitnessPal to MacroFactor?
Yes. Export your MyFitnessPal history first. MacroFactor needs a couple of weeks of consistent logging and weigh-ins before its expenditure estimate settles.
Data-driven calorie targets, without a subscription.
Start free, no card neededFree plan. No credit card. Web, Android and iPhone.